Rework on motion comments (fixes #3350).

openslides/core/config.py

@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ INPUT_TYPE_MAPPING = {
     'integer': int,
     'boolean': bool,
     'choice': str,
-    'comments': list,
+    'comments': dict,
     'colorpicker': str,
     'datetimepicker': int,
     'majorityMethod': str,
@@ -101,17 +101,29 @@ class ConfigHandler:
                 raise ConfigError(e.messages[0])
 
         if config_variable.input_type == 'comments':
-            if not isinstance(value, list):
+            if not isinstance(value, dict):
-                raise ConfigError(_('motions_comments has to be a list.'))
+                raise ConfigError(_('motions_comments has to be a dict.'))
-            for comment in value:
+            valuecopy = dict()
-                if not isinstance(comment, dict):
+            for id, commentsfield in value.items():
-                    raise ConfigError(_('Each element in motions_comments has to be a dict.'))
+                try:
-                if comment.get('name') is None or comment.get('public') is None:
+                    id = int(id)
+                except ValueError:
+                    raise ConfigError(_('Each id has to be an int.'))
+
+                if id < 1:
+                    raise ConfigError(_('Each id has to be greater then 0.'))
+                # Deleted commentsfields are saved as None to block the used ids
+                if commentsfield is not None:
+                    if not isinstance(commentsfield, dict):
+                        raise ConfigError(_('Each commentsfield in motions_comments has to be a dict.'))
+                    if commentsfield.get('name') is None or commentsfield.get('public') is None:
                         raise ConfigError(_('A name and a public property have to be given.'))
-                if not isinstance(comment['name'], str):
+                    if not isinstance(commentsfield['name'], str):
                         raise ConfigError(_('name has to be string.'))
-                if not isinstance(comment['public'], bool):
+                    if not isinstance(commentsfield['public'], bool):
                         raise ConfigError(_('public property has to be bool.'))
+                valuecopy[id] = commentsfield
+            value = valuecopy
 
         if config_variable.input_type == 'logo':
             if not isinstance(value, dict):

openslides/core/static/js/core/site.js

@@ -743,15 +743,6 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.core.site', [
     }
 ])
 
-.filter('excludeSpecialComments', function () {
-    return function (comments) {
-        return _.filter(comments, function (comment) {
-            var specialComment = comment.forState || comment.forRecommendation;
-            return !specialComment;
-        });
-    };
-})
-
 // angular formly config options
 .run([
     'formlyConfig',
@@ -1124,14 +1115,20 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.core.site', [
 
         // For comments input
         $scope.addComment = function (configOption, parent) {
-            parent.value.push({
+            var maxId = _.max(_.keys(parent.value));
+            if (maxId === undefined) {
+                maxId = 1;
+            } else {
+                maxId = parseInt(maxId) + 1;
+            }
+            parent.value[maxId] = {
                 name: gettextCatalog.getString('New'),
                 public: false,
-            });
+            };
             $scope.save(configOption, parent.value);
         };
-        $scope.removeComment = function (configOption, parent, index) {
+        $scope.removeComment = function (configOption, parent, id) {
-            parent.value.splice(index, 1);
+            parent.value[id] = null;
             $scope.save(configOption, parent.value);
         };
 

openslides/core/static/templates/config-form-field.html

@@ -20,8 +20,11 @@
 
     <!-- comments -->
     <div class="input-comments" ng-if="type === 'comments'">
-      <div ng-repeat="entry in $parent.value | excludeSpecialComments" class="input-group">
+      <div ng-repeat="(id, field) in ($parent.value
-        <input ng-model="entry.name"
+        | excludeSpecialCommentsFields
+        | excludeDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields)"
+        class="input-group">
+        <input ng-model="field.name"
                ng-model-options="{debounce: 1000}"
                ng-change="save(configOption, $parent.value)"
                class="form-control"
@@ -29,12 +32,12 @@
                type="text">
         <span class="input-group-btn">
           <button type=button" class="btn btn-default"
-            ng-click="entry.public = !entry.public; save(configOption, $parent.value);">
+            ng-click="field.public = !field.public; save(configOption, $parent.value);">
-            <i class="fa" ng-class="entry.public ? 'fa-unlock' : 'fa-lock'"></i>
+            <i class="fa" ng-class="field.public ? 'fa-unlock' : 'fa-lock'"></i>
-            {{ (entry.public ? 'Public' : 'Private') | translate }}
+            {{ (field.public ? 'Public' : 'Private') | translate }}
           </button>
           <button type="button" class="btn btn-default"
-            ng-click="removeComment(configOption, $parent, $index)">
+            ng-click="removeComment(configOption, $parent, id)">
             <i class="fa fa-minus"></i>
             <translate>Remove</translate>
           </button>

openslides/motions/config_variables.py

@@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ def get_config_variables():
 
     yield ConfigVariable(
         name='motions_comments',
-        default_value=[],
+        default_value={},
         input_type='comments',
         label='Comment fields for motions',
         weight=353,

openslides/motions/migrations/0003_motion_comments.py

@@ -0,0 +1,60 @@
+# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
+from __future__ import unicode_literals
+
+from django.db import migrations
+
+
+def change_motions_comments(apps, schema_editor):
+    """
+    Index the comments fields in the config. Changing from an array to a dict with the
+    ids as keys. CHange all motions from an array for comments to a dict with the comments
+    field id as key to link motion comments and comments fields.
+    """
+    # We get the model from the versioned app registry;
+    # if we directly import it, it will be the wrong version.
+    ConfigStore = apps.get_model('core', 'ConfigStore')
+    Motion = apps.get_model('motions', 'Motion')
+
+    try:
+        config_comments_fields = ConfigStore.objects.get(key='motions_comments').value
+    except ConfigStore.DoesNotExist:
+        config_comments_fields = []  # The old default: An empty list.
+
+    comments_fields = {}
+    for index, field in enumerate(config_comments_fields):
+        comments_fields[index+1] = field
+
+    max_index = len(config_comments_fields)-1
+
+    try:
+        db_value = ConfigStore.objects.get(key='motions_comments')
+    except ConfigStore.DoesNotExist:
+        db_value = ConfigStore(key='motions_comments')
+    db_value.value = comments_fields
+    # We cannot provide skip_autoupdate=True here, becuase this object is a fake object. It does *not*
+    # inherit from the RESTModelMixin, so the save() methos from base_model.py (django's default)
+    # gets called. This is because we are in the core app and try to save a core model. See
+    # comments in PR #3376.
+    db_value.save()
+
+    for motion in Motion.objects.all():
+        comments = {}
+        for index, comment in enumerate(motion.comments or []):
+            if index > max_index:
+                break
+            comments[index+1] = comment
+        motion.comments = comments
+        motion.save(skip_autoupdate=True)
+
+
+class Migration(migrations.Migration):
+
+    dependencies = [
+        ('motions', '0002_misc_features'),
+    ]
+
+    operations = [
+        migrations.RunPython(
+            change_motions_comments
+        ),
+    ]

openslides/motions/models.py

@@ -167,7 +167,7 @@ class Motion(RESTModelMixin, models.Model):
 
     comments = JSONField(null=True)
     """
-    Configurable fields for comments. Contains a list of strings.
+    Configurable fields for comments.
     """
 
     # In theory there could be one then more agenda_item. But we support only

openslides/motions/serializers.py

@@ -105,11 +105,15 @@ class MotionCommentsJSONSerializerField(Field):
         """
         Checks that data is a list of strings.
         """
-        if type(data) is not list:
+        if type(data) is not dict:
-            raise ValidationError({'detail': 'Data must be an array.'})
+            raise ValidationError({'detail': 'Data must be a dict.'})
-        for element in data:
+        for id, comment in data.items():
-            if type(element) is not str:
+            try:
-                raise ValidationError({'detail': 'Data must be an array of strings.'})
+                id = int(id)
+            except ValueError:
+                raise ValidationError({'detail': 'Id must be an int.'})
+            if type(comment) is not str:
+                raise ValidationError({'detail': 'Comment must be a string.'})
         return data
 
 
@@ -317,9 +321,9 @@ class MotionSerializer(ModelSerializer):
             data['text'] = validate_html(data['text'])
         if 'reason' in data:
             data['reason'] = validate_html(data['reason'])
-        validated_comments = []
+        validated_comments = dict()
-        for comment in data.get('comments', []):
+        for id, comment in data.get('comments', {}).items():
-            validated_comments.append(validate_html(comment))
+            validated_comments[id] = validate_html(comment)
         data['comments'] = validated_comments
         return data
 

openslides/motions/static/js/motions/base.js

@@ -678,18 +678,32 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions', [
 
 // Service for generic comment fields
 .factory('MotionComment', [
+    '$filter',
     'Config',
     'operator',
     'Editor',
-    function (Config, operator, Editor) {
+    function ($filter, Config, operator, Editor) {
         return {
-            getFormFields: function () {
+            isSpecialCommentField: function (field) {
+                if (field) {
+                    return field.forState || field.forRecommendation;
+                } else {
+                    return false;
+                }
+            },
+            getCommentsFields: function () {
                 var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
-                return _.map(
+                return $filter('excludeDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields')(fields);
-                    _.filter(fields, function(element) { return !element.forState && !element.forRecommendation; }),
+            },
-                    function (field) {
+            getNoSpecialCommentsFields: function () {
+                var fields = this.getCommentsFields();
+                return $filter('excludeSpecialCommentsFields')(fields);
+            },
+            getFormFields: function () {
+                var fields = this.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
+                return _.map(fields, function (field, id) {
                         return {
-                            key: 'comment ' + field.name,
+                            key: 'comment_' + id,
                             type: 'editor',
                             templateOptions: {
                                 label: field.name,
@@ -704,36 +718,60 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions', [
             },
             populateFields: function (motion) {
                 // Populate content of motion.comments to the single comment
-                // fields like motion['comment MyComment'], motion['comment MyOtherComment'], ...
+                var fields = this.getCommentsFields();
-                var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+                if (motion.comments) {
-                if (!motion.comments) {
+                    _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
-                    motion.comments = [];
+                        motion['comment_' + id] = motion.comments[id];
-                }
+                    });
-                for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
-                    motion['comment ' + fields[i].name] = motion.comments[i];
                 }
             },
             populateFieldsReverse: function (motion) {
                 // Reverse equivalent to populateFields.
-                var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+                var fields = this.getCommentsFields();
-                motion.comments = [];
+                motion.comments = {};
-                for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
+                _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
-                    motion.comments.push(motion['comment ' + fields[i].name] || '');
+                    motion.comments[id] = motion['comment_' + id] || '';
-                }
+                });
             },
-            getFieldNameForFlag: function (flag) {
+            getFieldIdForFlag: function (flag) {
-                var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+                var fields = this.getCommentsFields();
-                var fieldName = '';
+                return _.findKey(fields, [flag, true]);
-                var index = _.findIndex(fields, [flag, true]);
-                if (index > -1) {
-                    fieldName = fields[index].name;
-                }
-                return fieldName;
             },
         };
     }
 ])
 
+.filter('excludeSpecialCommentsFields', [
+    'MotionComment',
+    function (MotionComment) {
+        return function (commentsFields) {
+            var withoutSpecialCommentsFields = {};
+            _.forEach(commentsFields, function (field, id) {
+                if (!MotionComment.isSpecialCommentField(field)) {
+                    withoutSpecialCommentsFields[id] = field;
+                }
+            });
+            return withoutSpecialCommentsFields;
+        };
+    }
+])
+
+.filter('excludeDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields', [
+    'MotionComment',
+    'operator',
+    function (MotionComment, operator) {
+        return function (commentsFields) {
+            var withoutDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields = {};
+            _.forEach(commentsFields, function (field, id) {
+                if (field && (field.public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_see_and_manage_comments'))) {
+                    withoutDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields[id] = field;
+                }
+            });
+            return withoutDeletedAndForbiddenCommentsFields;
+        };
+    }
+])
+
 .factory('Category', [
     'DS',
     function(DS) {

openslides/motions/static/js/motions/docx.js

@@ -14,7 +14,9 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.docx', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.docx'])
     'FileSaver',
     'lineNumberingService',
     'Html2DocxConverter',
-    function ($http, $q, operator, Config, Category, gettextCatalog, FileSaver, lineNumberingService, Html2DocxConverter) {
+    'MotionComment',
+    function ($http, $q, operator, Config, Category, gettextCatalog, FileSaver, lineNumberingService,
+        Html2DocxConverter, MotionComment) {
 
         var PAGEBREAK = '<w:p><w:r><w:br w:type="page" /></w:r></w:p>';
 
@@ -153,19 +155,15 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.docx', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.docx'])
         };
 
         var getMotionComments = function (motion) {
-            var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+            var fields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
-            var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
-                return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
-            };
             var comments = [];
-            for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
+            _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
-                if (motion.comments[i] && canSeeComment(i)) {
+                if (motion.comments[id]) {
-                    var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + fields[i].name;
+                    var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + field.name;
-                    if (!fields[i].public) {
+                    if (!field.public) {
                         title += ' (' + gettextCatalog.getString('internal') + ')';
                     }
-                    var comment = motion.comments[i];
+                    var comment = motion.comments[id];
                     if (comment.indexOf('<p>') !== 0) {
                         comment = '<p>' + comment + '</p>';
                     }
@@ -174,7 +172,7 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.docx', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.docx'])
                         comment: comment,
                     });
                 }
-            }
+            });
             return comments;
         };
 

openslides/motions/static/js/motions/motion-services.js

@@ -134,14 +134,14 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.motionservices', ['OpenSlidesApp.motions',
                 editors: []
             };
             var options = Editor.getOptions('inline', 'YOffset');
-            _.forEach($scope.commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments, function (field) {
+            _.forEach($scope.noSpecialCommentsFields, function (field, id) {
                 var inlineEditing = MotionInlineEditing.createInstance($scope, motion,
-                    'view-original-comment-inline-editor-' + field.name, false, options,
+                    'view-original-comment-inline-editor-' + id, false, options,
                     function (obj) {
-                        return motion['comment ' + field.name];
+                        return motion['comment_' + id];
                     },
                     function (obj) {
-                        motion['comment ' + field.name] = obj.editor.getData();
+                        motion['comment_' + id] = obj.editor.getData();
                     }
                 );
                 commentsInlineEditing.editors.push(inlineEditing);

openslides/motions/static/js/motions/pdf.js

@@ -15,7 +15,9 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
     'Category',
     'Config',
     'Motion',
-    function($q, operator, gettextCatalog, PDFLayout, PdfMakeConverter, ImageConverter, HTMLValidizer, Category, Config, Motion) {
+    'MotionComment',
+    function($q, operator, gettextCatalog, PDFLayout, PdfMakeConverter, ImageConverter, HTMLValidizer,
+        Category, Config, Motion, MotionComment) {
         /**
          * Provides the content as JS objects for Motions in pdfMake context
          * @constructor
@@ -27,10 +29,19 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
             var converter;
 
             // Query all image sources from motion text and reason
-            // TODO: Do we need images for comments here too??
             var getImageSources = function () {
                 var text = motion.getTextByMode(changeRecommendationMode, null);
-                var content = HTMLValidizer.validize(text) + HTMLValidizer.validize(motion.getReason());
+                var reason = motion.getReason();
+                var comments = '';
+                if (includeComments) {
+                    var fields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
+                    _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
+                        if (motion.comments[id]) {
+                            comments += HTMLValidizer.validize(motion.comments[id]);
+                        }
+                    });
+                }
+                var content = HTMLValidizer.validize(text) + HTMLValidizer.validize(motion.getReason()) + comments;
                 var map = Function.prototype.call.bind([].map);
                 return map($(content).find('img'), function(element) {
                     return element.getAttribute('src');
@@ -298,16 +309,12 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
             // motion comments handling
             var motionComments = function () {
                 if (includeComments) {
-                    var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+                    var fields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
-                    var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                        var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
-                        return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
-                    };
                     var comments = [];
-                    for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
+                    _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
-                        if (motion.comments[i] && canSeeComment(i)) {
+                        if (motion.comments[id]) {
-                            var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + fields[i].name;
+                            var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + field.name;
-                            if (!fields[i].public) {
+                            if (!field.public) {
                                 title += ' (' + gettextCatalog.getString('internal') + ')';
                             }
                             comments.push({
@@ -315,9 +322,9 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
                                 style: 'heading3',
                                 marginTop: 25,
                             });
-                            comments.push(converter.convertHTML(motion.comments[i]));
+                            comments.push(converter.convertHTML(motion.comments[id]));
-                        }
                         }
+                    });
                     return comments;
                 }
             };
@@ -859,12 +866,13 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
     'PdfCreate',
     'PDFLayout',
     'PersonalNoteManager',
+    'MotionComment',
     'Messaging',
     'FileSaver',
     function ($http, $q, operator, Config, gettextCatalog, MotionChangeRecommendation, HTMLValidizer,
         PdfMakeConverter, MotionContentProvider, MotionCatalogContentProvider, PdfMakeDocumentProvider,
         PollContentProvider, PdfMakeBallotPaperProvider, MotionPartialContentProvider, PdfCreate,
-        PDFLayout, PersonalNoteManager, Messaging, FileSaver) {
+        PDFLayout, PersonalNoteManager, MotionComment, Messaging, FileSaver) {
         return {
             getDocumentProvider: function (motions, params, singleMotion) {
                 params = _.clone(params || {}); // Clone this to avoid sideeffects.
@@ -1008,24 +1016,20 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
                 });
             },
             exportComments: function (motion, filename) {
-                var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+                var fields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
-                var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                    var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
-                    return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
-                };
                 var content = [];
-                for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
+                _.forEach(fields, function (field, id) {
-                    if (motion.comments[i] && canSeeComment(i)) {
+                    if (motion.comments[id]) {
-                        var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + fields[i].name;
+                        var title = gettextCatalog.getString('Comment') + ' ' + field.name;
-                        if (!fields[i].public) {
+                        if (!field.public) {
                             title += ' (' + gettextCatalog.getString('internal') + ')';
                         }
                         content.push({
                             heading: title,
-                            text: motion.comments[i],
+                            text: motion.comments[id],
                         });
                     }
-                }
+                });
                 MotionPartialContentProvider.createInstance(motion, content).then(function (contentProvider) {
                     PdfMakeDocumentProvider.createInstance(contentProvider).then(function (documentProvider) {
                         PdfCreate.download(documentProvider.getDocument(), filename);

openslides/motions/static/js/motions/site.js

@@ -910,11 +910,10 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.site', [
         $scope.alert = {};
 
         // Motion comments
-        $scope.commentsFields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+        $scope.noSpecialCommentsFields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
-        $scope.commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments = _.filter($scope.commentsFields, function (field) {
+        $scope.showCommentsFilter = function () {
-            var specialComment = field.forState || field.forRecommendation;
+            return _.keys($scope.noSpecialCommentsFields).length > 0;
-            return !specialComment;
+        };
-        });
 
         // collect all states and all recommendations of all workflows
         $scope.states = [];
@@ -1289,13 +1288,10 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.site', [
                 });
             }
         };
-        $scope.commentsFields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
+        $scope.commentsFields = MotionComment.getCommentsFields();
-        $scope.commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments = _.filter($scope.commentsFields, function (field) {
+        $scope.noSpecialCommentsFields = MotionComment.getNoSpecialCommentsFields();
-            var specialComment = field.forState || field.forRecommendation;
+        $scope.commentFieldForStateId = MotionComment.getFieldIdForFlag('forState');
-            return !specialComment;
+        $scope.commentFieldForRecommendationId = MotionComment.getFieldIdForFlag('forRecommendation');
-        });
-        $scope.commentFieldForState = MotionComment.getFieldNameForFlag('forState');
-        $scope.commentFieldForRecommendation = MotionComment.getFieldNameForFlag('forRecommendation');
         $scope.version = motion.active_version;
         $scope.isCollapsed = true;
         $scope.lineNumberMode = Config.get('motions_default_line_numbering').value;
@@ -1402,14 +1398,14 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.site', [
         // save additional state field
         $scope.saveAdditionalStateField = function (stateExtension) {
             if (stateExtension) {
-                motion["comment " + $scope.commentFieldForState] = stateExtension;
+                motion['comment_' + $scope.commentFieldForStateId] = stateExtension;
                 $scope.save(motion);
             }
         };
         // save additional recommendation field
         $scope.saveAdditionalRecommendationField = function (recommendationExtension) {
             if (recommendationExtension) {
-                motion["comment " + $scope.commentFieldForRecommendation] = recommendationExtension;
+                motion['comment_' + $scope.commentFieldForRecommendationId] = recommendationExtension;
                 $scope.save(motion);
             }
         };
@@ -1471,18 +1467,9 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.site', [
                     $scope.showVersion({id: motion.active_version});
                 });
         };
-        // check if user is allowed to see at least one comment field
+        // check if there is at least one comment field
-        $scope.isAllowedToSeeCommentField = function () {
+        $scope.commentFieldsAvailable = function () {
-            var isAllowed = false;
+            return _.keys($scope.noSpecialCommentsFields).length > 0;
-            if ($scope.commentsFields.length > 0) {
-                isAllowed = operator.hasPerms('motions.can_see_and_manage_comments') || _.find(
-                        $scope.commentsFields,
-                        function(field) {
-                            return field.public && !field.forState && !field.forRecommendation;
-                        }
-                );
-            }
-            return Boolean(isAllowed);
         };
         // personal note
         // For pinning the personal note container we need to adjust the width with JS. We

openslides/motions/static/templates/motions/motion-detail.html

@@ -161,10 +161,10 @@
           </div>
           <div os-perms="motions.can_manage" class="input-group spacer"
               ng-show="motion.state.show_state_extension_field">
-            <label class="sr-only" for="stateExtensionField">{{ commentFieldForState }}</label>
+            <label class="sr-only" for="stateExtensionField">{{ commentsFields[commentFieldForStateId] }}</label>
             <input type="text" ng-model="stateExtension"
                 id="stateNameExtensionField" class="form-control input-sm"
-                placeholder="{{ commentFieldForState }}">
+                placeholder="{{ commentsFields[commentFieldForStateId] }}">
             <span class="input-group-btn">
               <button ng-click="saveAdditionalStateField(stateExtension)" class="btn btn-default btn-sm">
                 <i class="fa fa-check"></i>
@@ -203,10 +203,12 @@
             </div>
             <div class="input-group spacer"
                 ng-if="motion.recommendation.show_recommendation_extension_field">
-              <label class="sr-only" for="recommendationExtensionField">{{ commentFieldForRecommendation }}</label>
+              <label class="sr-only" for="recommendationExtensionField">
+                {{ commentsFields[commentFieldForRecommendationId] }}
+              </label>
               <input type="text" ng-model="recommendationExtension"
                   id="recommendationExtensionField" class="form-control input-sm"
-                  placeholder="{{ commentFieldForRecommendation }}">
+                  placeholder="{{ commentsFields[commentFieldForRecommendationId] }}">
               <span class="input-group-btn">
                 <button ng-click="saveAdditionalRecommendationField(recommendationExtension)" class="btn btn-default btn-sm">
                   <i class="fa fa-check"></i>

openslides/motions/static/templates/motions/motion-detail/comments.html

@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-<div class="details" ng-if="isAllowedToSeeCommentField() && commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments.length">
+<div class="details" ng-if="commentFieldsAvailable()">
   <div class="row">
     <!-- inline editing toolbar -->
     <div class="motion-toolbar">
@@ -25,15 +25,13 @@
     </div>
     <!-- comment fields -->
     <div class="col-sm-12">
-      <div ng-repeat="field in commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments">
+      <div ng-repeat="(id, field) in noSpecialCommentsFields">
-        <div ng-if="operator.hasPerms('motions.can_see_and_manage_comments') && !field.forState && !field.forRecommendation">
         <h4>
           {{ field.name }}
           <span ng-if="!field.public" class="label label-warning" translate>internal</span>
         </h4>
-          <div id="view-original-comment-inline-editor-{{ field.name }}" style="min-height: 14px;"
+        <div id="view-original-comment-inline-editor-{{ id }}" style="min-height: 14px;"
-            ng-bind-html="motion.comments[$index] | trusted" contenteditable="{{ commentsInlineEditing.editors[$index].isEditable }}"></div>
+          ng-bind-html="motion.comments[id] | trusted" contenteditable="{{ commentsInlineEditing.editors[$index].isEditable }}"></div>
-        </div>
       </div>
       <!-- save toolbar -->
       <div class="motion-save-toolbar" ng-class="{ 'visible': commentsInlineEditing.saveToolbarVisible() }">

openslides/motions/static/templates/motions/motion-list.html

@@ -169,8 +169,7 @@
             </ul>
           </span>
           <!-- Comment filter -->
-          <span os-perms="motions.can_see_and_manage_comments">
+          <span uib-dropdown ng-if="showCommentsFilter()">
-            <span uib-dropdown ng-if="commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments.length > 0">
             <span class="pointer" id="dropdownComment" uib-dropdown-toggle
               ng-class="{'bold': filter.multiselectFilters.comment.length > 0, 'disabled': isSelectMode}"
               ng-disabled="isSelectMode">
@@ -178,7 +177,7 @@
               <span class="caret"></span>
             </span>
             <ul class="dropdown-menu dropdown-menu-left" aria-labelledby="dropdownComment">
-                <li ng-repeat="commentsField in commentsFieldsNoSpecialComments">
+              <li ng-repeat="commentsField in noSpecialCommentsFields">
                 <a href ng-click="filter.operateMultiselectFilter('comment', commentsField.name, isSelectMode)">
                   <i class="fa fa-check" ng-if="filter.multiselectFilters.comment.indexOf(commentsField.name) > -1"></i>
                   {{ commentsField.name }} <translate>is set</translate>
@@ -193,7 +192,6 @@
               </li>
             </ul>
           </span>
-          </span>
           <!-- recommendation filter -->
           <span uib-dropdown ng-if="config('motions_recommendations_by') != ''">
             <span class="pointer" id="dropdownRecommendation" uib-dropdown-toggle

tests/integration/motions/test_viewset.py

@@ -238,10 +238,9 @@ class CreateMotion(TestCase):
         self.assertEqual(motion.tags.get().name, 'test_tag_iRee3kiecoos4rorohth')
 
     def test_with_multiple_comments(self):
-        config['motions_comments'] = [
+        comments = {
-            {'name': 'comment1', 'public': True},
+            '1': 'comemnt1_sdpoiuffo3%7dwDwW)',
-            {'name': 'comment2', 'public': False}]
+            '2': 'comment2_iusd_D/TdskDWH(5DWas46WAd078'}
-        comments = ['comemnt1_sdpoiuffo3%7dwDwW)', 'comment2_iusd_D/TdskDWH(5DWas46WAd078']
         response = self.client.post(
             reverse('motion-list'),
             {'title': 'title_test_sfdAaufd56HR7sd5FDq7av',
@@ -252,6 +251,31 @@ class CreateMotion(TestCase):
         motion = Motion.objects.get()
         self.assertEqual(motion.comments, comments)
 
+    def test_wrong_comment_format(self):
+        comments = [
+            'comemnt1_wpcjlwgj$§ks)skj2LdmwKDWSLw6',
+            'comment2_dq2Wd)Jwdlmm:,w82DjwQWSSiwjd']
+        response = self.client.post(
+            reverse('motion-list'),
+            {'title': 'title_test_sfdAaufd56HR7sd5FDq7av',
+             'text': 'text_test_fiuhefF86()ew1Ef346AF6W',
+             'comments': comments},
+            format='json')
+        self.assertEqual(response.status_code, status.HTTP_400_BAD_REQUEST)
+        self.assertEqual(response.data, {'comments': {'detail': 'Data must be a dict.'}})
+
+    def test_wrong_comment_id(self):
+        comment = {
+            'string': 'comemnt1_wpcjlwgj$§ks)skj2LdmwKDWSLw6'}
+        response = self.client.post(
+            reverse('motion-list'),
+            {'title': 'title_test_sfdAaufd56HR7sd5FDq7av',
+             'text': 'text_test_fiuhefF86()ew1Ef346AF6W',
+             'comments': comment},
+            format='json')
+        self.assertEqual(response.status_code, status.HTTP_400_BAD_REQUEST)
+        self.assertEqual(response.data, {'comments': {'detail': 'Id must be an int.'}})
+
     def test_with_workflow(self):
         """
         Test to create a motion with a specific workflow.
@@ -298,13 +322,12 @@ class CreateMotion(TestCase):
             reverse('motion-list'),
             {'title': 'test_title_peiJozae0luew9EeL8bo',
              'text': 'test_text_eHohS8ohr5ahshoah8Oh',
-             'comments': ['comment_for_field_one__xiek1Euhae9xah2wuuraaaa'],
+             'comments': {'1': 'comment_for_field_one__xiek1Euhae9xah2wuuraaaa'}},
-             'comment_field_one': 'comment_for_field_one__xiek1Euhae9xah2wuuraaaa'},
             format='json',
         )
 
         self.assertEqual(response.status_code, status.HTTP_201_CREATED)
-        self.assertEqual(Motion.objects.get().comments, ['comment_for_field_one__xiek1Euhae9xah2wuuraaaa'])
+        self.assertEqual(Motion.objects.get().comments, {'1': 'comment_for_field_one__xiek1Euhae9xah2wuuraaaa'})
 
     def test_amendment_motion(self):
         """