diff --git a/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/docx.js b/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/docx.js
index ede74639f..31ba35ac3 100644
--- a/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/docx.js
+++ b/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/docx.js
@@ -153,7 +153,8 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.docx', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.docx'])
         var getMotionComments = function (motion) {
             var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
             var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                return fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage');
+                var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
+                return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
             };
             var comments = [];
             for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
diff --git a/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/pdf.js b/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/pdf.js
index 205bcbca9..3f4f87401 100644
--- a/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/pdf.js
+++ b/openslides/motions/static/js/motions/pdf.js
@@ -298,7 +298,8 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
                 if (includeComments) {
                     var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
                     var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                        return fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage');
+                        var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
+                        return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
                     };
                     var comments = [];
                     for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {
@@ -958,7 +959,8 @@ angular.module('OpenSlidesApp.motions.pdf', ['OpenSlidesApp.core.pdf'])
             exportComments: function (motion, filename) {
                 var fields = Config.get('motions_comments').value;
                 var canSeeComment = function (index) {
-                    return fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage');
+                    var specialComment = fields[index].forState || fields[index].forRecommendation;
+                    return (fields[index].public || operator.hasPerms('motions.can_manage')) && !specialComment;
                 };
                 var content = [];
                 for (var i = 0; i < fields.length; i++) {